Bowls of ice cream with pizzelle cookies beside chocolate and caramel cake slices on a confetti-scattered table

Gifts $50 to $100

Filter

    The full cake. The whole gesture. Seven layers, iced by hand, arriving in the red tin that has been our calling card since Caroline's front porch.

    33 products
    Bestseller
    A round caramel cake cut open to reveal seven tender yellow layers, finished in swirled caramel icing.
    A slice of seven-layer caramel cake served on blue and white china with a silver fork.
    7-Layer Caramel Cake
    $70.00
    A rainbow-sprinkled cake cut to show seven lemon layers with fruit fillings.
    A slice of rainbow sprinkle cake topped with whipped cream and sprinkles.
    Sprinkle Rainbow Cake
    $90.00
    Gluten Free
    A gluten free caramel cake cut open to show seven layers in caramel icing.
    A tall slice of gluten free caramel cake, seven layers and caramel icing.
    Gluten Free Caramel Cake
    $90.00
    Gluten Free
    A gluten free coconut cake cut open to show four layers in fresh coconut icing.
    A slice of gluten free coconut cake on floral china, the first forkful taken.
    Gluten Free Coconut Cloud
    $90.00
    Gluten Free
    A gluten free chocolate cake cut open to show four layers in dark chocolate icing.
    Gluten Free Southern Chocolate
    $90.00
    Half caramel and half coconut in one cake, seven caramel layers beside four coconut.
    A half caramel, half coconut cake on a white stand, its two halves cut open.
    1/2 Caramel and 1/2 Coconut Cloud
    $85.00
    Half caramel and half Southern chocolate in one cake, cut to show seven layers.
    A half caramel, half chocolate cake on a white stand, seven layers throughout.
    1/2 Caramel and 1/2 Southern Chocolate
    $85.00
    A barbecue spread on a wooden table with pulled pork, chicken, slaw, beans and rolls.
    Carolina-Style BBQ Party
    $85.00
    A seven-layer chocolate cake cut open, dark layers and glossy chocolate icing.
    A slice of seven-layer chocolate cake lifted on a gold server.
    7-Layer Bliss
    $80.00
    Sold Out
    A black forest cake in cream cheese icing and chocolate curls, cut to show four layers.
    A slice of black forest cake topped with a cherry, chocolate curls at the side.
    Black Forest Cake
    $80.00
    Bestseller
    A Southern chocolate cake cut open to show seven yellow layers in dark chocolate icing.
    A tall slice of seven-layer chocolate cake on stacked blue and white plates.
    Southern Chocolate
    $80.00
    Sold Out
    Seven layers of caramel cake iced in white and finished with rainbow sprinkles.
    A slice of seven-layer caramel cake topped with whipped cream and sprinkles.
    Sprinkle Caramel Cake
    $80.00
    Seven layers of yellow cake and chocolate, iced in white with rainbow sprinkles.
    A tall slice of seven-layer chocolate cake on a blue ruffled plate.
    Sprinkle Southern Chocolate
    $80.00
    Four layers of vanilla cake iced in white and finished with rainbow sprinkles.
    A tall slice of four-layer vanilla cake with buttercream and rainbow sprinkles.
    Sprinkle Vanilla
    $80.00
    Sold Out
    Four layers of devil's food cake iced in white and finished with rainbow sprinkles.
    A sprinkle-covered cake on a pink glass stand with confetti and iced cookies.
    Sprinkle Devil's Food
    $80.00
    A white-iced cake cut open to show seven lemon layers with rainbow fillings.
    A slice of rainbow cake on floral china, seven lemon layers in bright fillings.
    Rainbow Cake
    $80.00
    A seven-layer caramel cake beside its custom Birdie's Flight tin lid.
    A caramel cake and a plated slice on a marble table, the Birdie's Flight tin alongside.
    Birdie's Flight Caramel Cake
    $80.00
    A seven-layer caramel cake in rainbow sprinkles, beside its Penny's Flight tin lid.
    Penny's Flight Sprinkle Caramel Cake
    $80.00
    An overhead tray of ice cream bowls with caramel, chocolate, coconut and sprinkles, beside waffle cones and a Montana Gold pint.
    Four pints of Caroline's Cakes ice cream stacked together: Montana Gold, Caramel Cake, Caramel and Coconut Cake, a lid propped alongside.
    Best Sellers Ice Cream Bundle
    $72.00
    An overhead birthday table with slices of caramel, Montana Gold and lemon cake, bowls of ice cream, confetti and party hats.
    A stack of four Caroline's Cakes ice cream pints: Montana Gold, Caramel Cake, Lemon and Coconut Cake, with a Caramel Cake lid propped alongside.
    Caroline’s Picks Ice Cream Bundle
    $72.00
    Sale
    A footed glass dish of peach raspberry ice cream with a silver spoon, more glass dishes and a striped pint nearby.
    A pint of Caroline's Cakes Peach Raspberry ice cream on marble, fresh peaches and raspberries beside it.
    The Sweet Summer Scoop Bundle
    $72.00 $54.00 Save $18.00
    A lemon cake cut open to show seven layers filled with lemon buttercream.
    A lemon cake set on blue and white china with plated slices and a yellow rose.
    7-Layer Lemon
    $70.00
    A coconut cake cut open to show four yellow layers and snowy white coconut icing.
    A slice of coconut cake on blue and white china, the first forkful taken.
    Coconut Cloud Cake
    $70.00
    A coconut cake cut open to show four yellow layers and bright lemon curd.
    A slice of coconut lemon cake on a blush plate, coconut scattered on marble.
    Coconut Lemon Delight
    $70.00
    A carrot cake cut open to show four spiced layers between white cream cheese icing.
    A slice of carrot cake on a leaf-patterned plate, hydrangeas behind.
    Carrot Cake Traditional
    $70.00
    A carrot cake iced in white, cut to show four spiced layers with caramel.
    A slice of carrot caramel cake with the whole cake on a green stand behind.
    Carrot Caramel Delight
    $70.00
    Sold Out
    A chocolate cake in caramel icing, cut to show four dark layers.
    A slice of chocolate caramel cake on a white plate, a spoonful lifted away.
    Montana Gold
    $70.00
    A pink champagne cake in rosé buttercream, cut to show four layers.
    Three slices of pink champagne cake on rose-bordered china with glasses of rosé.
    Pink Champagne Cake
    $70.00
    A red velvet cake cut open to show four red layers between white cream cheese icing.
    A tall slice of red velvet cake on a white plate with a silver fork.
    Red Velvet Traditional
    $70.00
    A stack of four Caroline's Cakes ice cream pints: Montana Gold, Caramel Cake, Lemon and Coconut Cake, with a Caramel Cake lid propped alongside.
    An animation cycling through five Caroline's Cakes pints: Caramel Cake, Lemon, Coconut Cake, Caramel and Montana Gold.
    Build Your Own Ice Cream Bundle- 4 Pint Pack
    $72.00
    A seven-layer caramel cake beside a custom tin bearing Marvin Hamlisch's portrait.
    Marvin Hamlisch Caramel Cake
    $80.00
    A seven-layer caramel cake beside its custom Stand Up To Cancer tin lid.
    Stand Up To Cancer Caramel Cake
    $80.00