Overhead view of caramel, chocolate, coconut and spice cake slices on white plates along a green floral table runner

Best-Selling Gifts

Filter

    When you want the sure thing. These are the cakes our customers send again and again, to people they cannot afford to disappoint. Start here.

    14 products
    Bestseller
    A round caramel cake cut open to reveal seven tender yellow layers, finished in swirled caramel icing.
    A slice of seven-layer caramel cake served on blue and white china with a silver fork.
    7-Layer Caramel Cake
    $70.00
    Sold Out
    A seven-layer chocolate cake cut open, dark layers and glossy chocolate icing.
    A slice of seven-layer chocolate cake lifted on a gold server.
    7-Layer Bliss
    $80.00
    A coconut cake cut open to show four yellow layers and snowy white coconut icing.
    Slices of coconut cake on blue and white china, the whole cake behind.
    Coconut Cloud Cake
    $70.00
    A carrot cake iced in white, cut to show four spiced layers with caramel.
    A slice of carrot caramel cake on gold-rimmed china with a gilded pine cone.
    Carrot Caramel Delight
    $70.00
    A slice of black forest cake on a navy plate with two cherries.
    A slice of black forest cake topped with a cherry, chocolate curls at the side.
    Black Forest Cake
    $80.00
    A blackberry lime cake in blackberry buttercream, cut to show four layers.
    Three slices of blackberry lime cake on sage plates with purple blooms.
    Blackberry Lime Cake
    $70.00
    Bestseller
    A Southern chocolate cake cut open to show seven yellow layers in dark chocolate icing.
    A tall slice of seven-layer chocolate cake on stacked blue and white plates.
    Southern Chocolate
    $80.00
    Three Caroline's cakes cut open on white pedestal stands: coconut, caramel and Southern Chocolate.
    Three red Caroline's Cakes tins with three classic cakes: caramel, chocolate and coconut.
    Southern Classics Bundle- 3 Cakes
    $210.00
    Sold Out
    Wedges of chocolate cake on white, iced in caramel, dark chocolate and white, each cut to show its layers.
    Three red Caroline's Cakes tins with three chocolate cakes, iced in caramel, milk chocolate and dark chocolate.
    Chocolate Lover Bundle- 3 Cakes
    $220.00
    The Sprinkle Caramel Cake on a pink stand at an outdoor party table, with lemonade, confetti and cake bites.
    A stop-motion of candles spelling Happy Birthday appearing one by one on a sprinkle cake, then lighting.
    Birthday Bundle
    $110.00
    Sale
    An overhead board of Caroline's cheese biscuits, cake bites and pimento cheese with grapes, apples, cheeses and crackers.
    An open yellow gift box of Caroline's cheese biscuits with a note inside the lid, two more boxes and cake bites beside it.
    The Host with the Most Bundle- Cake Bites & Cheese Biscuits
    $50.00 $37.50 Save $12.50
    Sale
    Caramel Cake Bite Box- 40 Pack
    $70.00 $56.00 Save $14.00
    An open yellow gift box of Southern cheese biscuits in two trays.
    Cheese biscuits in a napkin-lined silver dish, the lid lifted away.
    Southern Cheese Biscuits
    $20.00
    An overhead tray of ice cream bowls with caramel, chocolate, coconut and sprinkles, beside waffle cones and a Montana Gold pint.
    Four pints of Caroline's Cakes ice cream stacked together: Montana Gold, Caramel Cake, Caramel and Coconut Cake, a lid propped alongside.
    Best Sellers Ice Cream Bundle
    $72.00