Small-batch crafted with care in a separate creamery that also processes nut products.

Experience an indulgent quartet inspired by our legendary cakes. Select any four pints of our hand-blended ice cream, then savor every scoop of sweet nostalgia.

Tasting Notes

• Caramel Cake: Vanilla ice cream blended with pieces of yellow cake and rich caramel icing for a creamy, buttery scoop of Southern tradition.

• Caramel: Our classic vanilla ice cream enriched with swirls of our legendary caramel, for a luscious and velvety indulgence.

• Montana Gold: Chocolate ice cream blended with caramel icing, combining smooth cocoa notes and our famous caramel icing.

• Coconut Cake: Creamy coconut ice cream with coconut icing and tender yellow cake pieces, delivering coconut bliss and fluffy cake in every bite.

• Lemon: A refreshing lemon ice cream blended with house-made lemon curd to balance bright citrus tartness with sweet creaminess.

• Peach Raspberry: A creamy peach ice cream layered with house-made raspberry coulis to capture the taste of ripe summer fruit in every spoonful.

Mix and match your favorite flavors to enjoy a signature ice cream sampler of Caroline’s classics.

Must Order 4 Pints

Birthday Party in a Box